Government Response To Tackling Non-Compliance in the Umbrella Company Market

In recent years, the UK's labour market has witnessed a significant rise in the use of umbrella companies, with HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) analysis indicating that at least 700,000 workers were engaged through such entities during the 2022 to 2023 period. However, concerns have emerged regarding non-compliance within this sector, leading to substantial tax losses and the exploitation of workers. In response, the government has initiated measures to regulate umbrella companies, aiming to enhance compliance, protect workers, and ensure a fairer tax system.

Understanding Umbrella Companies

Umbrella companies serve as intermediaries in the labour market, employing temporary workers on behalf of recruitment agencies or end clients. They handle administrative tasks such as payroll processing, tax deductions, and compliance with employment laws. While they offer convenience, issues have arisen due to the lack of a clear legal definition and regulatory framework, leading to instances of tax avoidance and worker exploitation.

Government Initiatives to Address Non-Compliance

In June 2023, the government launched a consultation titled "Tackling Non-Compliance in the Umbrella Company Market" to gather insights on regulating umbrella companies and addressing tax non-compliance. The consultation received 75 responses from various stakeholders, highlighting widespread non-compliance that deprived workers of their rights and resulted in significant tax losses.

Based on the consultation findings, the government announced plans to shift the responsibility for Pay As You Earn (PAYE) tax deductions from umbrella companies to recruitment agencies or, in their absence, to end clients. This change, set to take effect from April 2026, aims to curb tax avoidance by ensuring that entities higher up the supply chain are accountable for tax compliance.

Implications for the Umbrella Company Market

• Enhanced Compliance: By holding recruitment agencies and end clients responsible for PAYE deductions, the government seeks to eliminate non-compliant umbrella companies that facilitate tax avoidance schemes. This move is expected to protect approximately £2.8 billion from being lost to non-compliance.
• Worker Protection: Shifting tax responsibilities up the supply chain is anticipated to reduce the exploitation of workers by unscrupulous umbrella companies. Workers should experience greater transparency regarding their employment terms and receive the full benefits and rights to which they are entitled.
• Industry Collaboration: The government intends to collaborate closely with industry stakeholders to implement these measures effectively, ensuring that compliant businesses are not unduly burdened while targeting those engaging in malpractice.

Shifting Responsibility for PAYE and Liability

The decision to shift responsibility for PAYE from umbrella companies to recruitment agencies or end clients marks a significant regulatory change. Once in effect, umbrella companies will no longer be legally accountable for PAYE tax payments, leaving recruitment agencies to ensure full compliance. This shift raises numerous questions about its practical implementation, many of which will be addressed in the forthcoming government update expected in July 2025.

The government’s long-term goal is to legally define what constitutes an umbrella company and bring the industry under the Employment Agency Standards Inspectorate. This move will align umbrella companies with other employment regulatory bodies, placing them under the oversight of the Fair Work Agency.

While this is a positive development, regulation alone has historically been ineffective at eliminating non-compliant practices. Bad actors may continue to operate, especially given the financial pressures caused by rising employer National Insurance contributions. Consequently, enforcement mechanisms must be strengthened to prevent tax avoidance and worker exploitation.

Challenges and Considerations

Despite the positive intentions behind these reforms, several challenges and considerations remain:

• Definition Clarity: The absence of a clear legal definition of what constitutes an umbrella company has been a longstanding issue. The government acknowledges this gap and plans to address it in forthcoming legislation.
• Business Concerns: Some business leaders have expressed apprehension that increased regulatory burdens could hinder economic growth. They argue that additional costs associated with compliance may deter investment and job creation.
• Implementation and Enforcement: Effectively enforcing the new regulations will require robust mechanisms to monitor compliance and address violations. The government's commitment to a zero-tolerance approach necessitates adequate resources and coordination among enforcement agencies.

Preparing for the Changes

As the April 2026 implementation date approaches, recruitment agencies must proactively adapt to the regulatory shift:

• Revising Preferred Supplier and Approved Supplier Lists: Agencies must reassess their PSLs and ASLs, ensuring that all partnerships align with the new regulations and compliance standards.
• Ensuring Real-Time Audits: Working only with umbrella companies that offer independent real-time tax audits can provide proof of PAYE compliance and reduce liability risks.
• Strengthening Due Diligence: Compliance checks and regular audits will become essential to avoid financial penalties associated with unpaid PAYE taxes.
• Worker Awareness: Educating workers about their rights and the implications of the new regulations will empower them to make informed decisions and identify potential exploitation.

In the current climate, contractors and businesses should avoid working with umbrella companies that cannot offer transparency and real-time tax compliance verification. Ensuring partnerships with audited, fully compliant providers is the best approach to safeguarding against financial and reputational risk.

The government’s response to the consultation on non-compliance in the umbrella company market marks a major shift in regulation and enforcement. By shifting PAYE responsibilities to agencies and end clients, introducing stricter compliance measures, and aiming to define umbrella companies legally, these reforms seek to create a fairer and more transparent industry.

However, with many details yet to be finalised, businesses must remain vigilant. The best course of action is to stay ahead of regulatory changes, ensure that all partners in the supply chain are compliant, and be prepared for the legislative shift expected in 2026. Proactive steps taken now will help safeguard businesses and workers from the risks associated with non-compliant umbrella company practices.

Verified Umbrella Companies – Preferred Suppliers List

Umbrella Company	Key Features	Fees	Company Profile
	Contracting Awards Winner FCSA Accreditation Professional Passport Approved Same day payments & wage advances on request All statutory entitlements holiday, sick pay etc. Exceptional customer service levels	£12/week	View Profile Request a Call Back
	SafeRec Certification Insurance - EL-£10m, PI-£2M, P&PL £5M Simple and transparent onboarding process Phone call support – get to speak to a real person IR35 worry free Continuity of employment	£10/week	View Profile Request a Call Back
	Professional Passport Approved Payroll flexibility (weekly, bi-weekly, monthly) Free tax investigation consultation* Free employment dispute advice* Insurance EL, PL, PI Full employment rights from day one	£19/week	View Profile Request a Call Back

If you need any help related to umbrella companies, please feel free to get in touch with us on [email protected]